Why extra payments save so much
Extra money paid toward principal skips the interest charge it would have collected over all the remaining months. Early in a long loan that adds up quickly: on a 30-year mortgage, an extra payment in year one saves interest for about 29 years.
Worked example: $300,000 at 6.5%, five ways to pay extra
A $300,000 mortgage at 6.5% with 360 months left has a payment of $1,896.20 and costs $382,636.71 in interest if you never pay extra. Here is what different extra payments do, each applied to principal from the first month:
| Extra payment | Paid off in | Sooner by | Total interest | Interest saved |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| None | 30 yr (360 payments) | — | $382,636.71 | — |
| $50 a month | 27 yr 10 mo (334) | 2 yr 2 mo | $349,054.20 | $33,582.51 |
| $100 a month | 26 yr (312) | 4 yr | $321,640.90 | $60,995.81 |
| $200 a month | 23 yr 1 mo (277) | 6 yr 11 mo | $279,186.52 | $103,450.19 |
| $2,400 once a year | 23 yr 3 mo (279) | 6 yr 9 mo | $282,964.47 | $99,672.24 |
| $500 a month | 17 yr 6 mo (210) | 12 yr 6 mo | $202,875.03 | $179,761.68 |
Two patterns stand out. Even $50 a month takes more than two years off a 30-year loan. And paying the same $2,400 a year as one lump at the end of each year saves $3,777.95 less than spreading it over the months as $200, because the monthly version starts reducing the balance (and the interest charged on it) eleven months sooner. That gap is real but small, so pick the schedule you will keep up.
Starting part-way through the loan
Extra payments save the most when they start early, because each dollar of principal you remove would otherwise have collected interest for the rest of the term. Ten years into the same loan you still owe about $254,329 with 240 payments left (the balance from the amortization schedule). Starting $200 a month extra then pays the loan off in 16 yr 7 mo instead of 20 years and saves $39,657.95, compared with $103,450.19 had the same $200 started in month one. It is still worth doing; it just buys less, so if you are choosing between starting now and “once things settle down”, sooner wins.
Prepaying a mortgage or a shorter loan
The return on an extra payment equals the loan’s interest rate, no more and no less. That makes the comparison with other uses of the money straightforward:
- The same $200 a month on a $300,000 loan at 3% saves $34,427.72 (and ends it 6 years sooner) instead of $103,450.19 at 6.5%. A low-rate loan is the last debt to prepay.
- On a 5-year $25,000 loan at 7.5% ($500.95 a month), $100 extra ends it 11 months early and saves $1,013.70. The dollar saving is smaller because the loan is shorter, but the rate earned on each extra dollar is the same 7.5%.
- Credit card balances usually cost far more than either. Paying down a 22.9% card first earns 22.9%; see the credit card payoff calculator or the debt payoff calculator to rank several debts.
What this calculator does and doesn’t model
- Does: a fixed extra amount every month, a fixed extra amount every 12th payment, or both, applied straight to principal on a fixed-rate loan, with the regular payment unchanged.
- One-time lump sums (a bonus or inheritance) are not an input. For a rough answer, rerun the calculator with the balance reduced by the lump sum; that shows the new interest but also lowers the payment, so it understates how soon the loan ends if you keep paying the old amount.
- Recasting: some servicers will recalculate a lower payment after a large prepayment, usually for a fee. The calculator assumes the payment stays the same and the loan ends sooner.
- Adjustable rates: after an ARM resets, both the payment and the savings change.
- Escrow and PMI: taxes and insurance are not included. Extra principal does bring the balance down to 80% of the original value sooner, when you can ask to cancel PMI (see the CFPB on PMI); the mortgage calculator shows when that happens without extra payments.
- Taxes: if you deduct mortgage interest, part of the interest saved would have reduced your taxes. Whether that applies depends on itemizing (IRS Publication 936); ask a tax professional.
Common mistakes
- Not telling the servicer it is principal. Money sent without instructions may be held as an early payment for next month instead of reducing the balance today. Mark it “apply to principal” and check the next statement.
- Expecting next month’s payment to drop. On a fixed-rate loan the required payment stays the same; the loan just ends sooner. Skipping a payment because you “paid ahead” usually isn’t allowed unless the money was applied as a future payment, which defeats the purpose.
- Prepaying while carrying high-rate debt. A 6.5% mortgage is a poor place for money that could pay off a 22.9% card.
- Emptying the emergency fund. Extra principal can’t be taken back out without a new loan or a home equity line, so keep cash for repairs and job loss first.
- Skipping an employer retirement match to prepay. A match is usually a larger, immediate return than any loan rate.
- Paying for a payment program. Services that charge setup or per-payment fees to “accelerate” your loan do nothing you can’t do yourself for free; see the biweekly mortgage calculator.
- Forgetting the prepayment penalty check. Rare on today’s home loans but still found on some auto, personal and business loans. Your Loan Estimate or loan contract says whether there is one.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to pay extra monthly or once a year?
Monthly extra payments save slightly more because the principal drops sooner, but the difference is small. Pick whatever you will stick with.
Does an extra payment lower my monthly payment?
Usually not. On most fixed-rate loans the payment stays the same and the loan simply ends sooner. Some lenders will recalculate (recast) the payment after a large lump sum, often for a fee.
Should I pay off my mortgage early or invest?
Prepaying earns a guaranteed return equal to your interest rate. Investing may earn more or less. Many people do some of both. This calculator shows the guaranteed side of that trade-off.
How much does an extra $100 a month save on a mortgage?
On a $300,000 loan at 6.5% over 30 years, $100 a month extra from the start saves $60,995.81 in interest and ends the loan 4 years early. Started 10 years into the loan, the savings are smaller because fewer months of interest are left to avoid.
Will paying extra get rid of PMI sooner?
Yes, indirectly. PMI on a conventional loan can be cancelled on request once the balance reaches 80% of the home’s original value and ends automatically at 78%. Extra principal reaches those points sooner. Ask your servicer for its cancellation requirements.
Can I get extra payments back if I need the money?
No. Once applied to principal, the money is part of your home equity and can only be reached by selling, refinancing or borrowing against the home. That is why an emergency fund usually comes first.
Sources
- CFPB: What is private mortgage insurance? (cancellation at 80% and 78%)
- IRS Publication 936: Home Mortgage Interest Deduction
- CFPB: Understanding your Loan Estimate (shows whether a loan has a prepayment penalty)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB): Buying a house
Last reviewed . How we review and test pages.