How the comparison works
Lease net cost = fees at signing + lease payments + purchase price at the end (if you buy) − equipment value (if you buy)
Loan net cost = down payment + loan fees + loan payments during the lease term + any loan balance left at the end − equipment value
Both sides are compared over the lease term. Lease payments are made at the start of each month and loan payments at the end, so each cash flow is discounted to today at your discount rate: what your cash earns or saves elsewhere. When you buy at lease end, the calculator also solves for the lease's implied interest rate, the rate at which the lease payments and purchase price repay the equipment price, so you can compare it directly with the loan rate.
Example
Equipment costs $50,000 and should be worth $10,000 after 5 years. A 60-month lease is $1,000 a month, returned at the end. A loan with 10% down at 8% for 60 months is $912.44 a month on $45,000. Before discounting, leasing costs $60,000 and buying nets $49,746 after counting the $10,000 you own. At a 5% discount rate, the lease costs $53,212 in today's dollars and the loan $45,559, so buying costs $7,653 less.
If the same lease has a $1 purchase option, its implied rate is 7.69% and leasing comes out $138 ahead, because you keep the equipment and pay no money down. A lease at $800 a month, returned at the end, costs $42,569 in today's dollars and beats the loan by $2,989. With a 36-month lease at $1,400 and a $25,000 value at month 36, the buy side pays off the remaining $20,174 loan balance and still comes out $15,617 ahead.
Worked scenario: a machine that holds its value vs. equipment that ages fast
A long-lived machine. A contractor needs an $80,000 machine expected to be worth about $40,000 after 5 years. A fair-market-value lease is $1,350 a month for 60 months with a $250 documentation fee, returned at the end. The loan option is 20% down at 8.5% for 60 months with a $500 fee: $1,313.06 a month on $64,000.
- The lease needs only $250 at signing against $16,500 for the loan, and its payment is just $36.94 a month higher.
- Over 5 years the lease costs $81,250 and leaves you with nothing. Buying costs $55,283 net of the $40,000 machine you keep.
- In today's dollars at a 5% discount rate that is $72,086 against $54,912, so buying costs $17,174 less.
- If you would buy the machine at its $40,000 fair market value when the lease ends, the lease's implied interest rate is 13.40%, against 8.5% on the loan.
- If the machine is worth only $25,000 after 5 years, buying still wins, but by $5,486 instead of $17,174. The end value is the input that moves the answer most.
Equipment that ages fast. A clinic needs $30,000 of computer-based equipment that will be worth about $4,000 after 3 years. A 36-month fair-market-value lease is $780 a month with $150 in fees, returned at the end. A loan with 10% down at 9% for 36 months with a $300 fee is $858.59 a month on $27,000. Leasing costs $28,230; buying costs $30,209 after counting the $4,000 resale value. In today's dollars that is $26,284 against $28,504, so leasing costs $2,220 less. You also hand the equipment back instead of having to sell it, and can lease the current model.
What this calculator does and doesn't model
It compares cash flows over the lease term: fees, payments (lease in advance, loan in arrears), the lease-end purchase or the loan balance still owed, and the equipment's value at the end, discounted to today. It does not model:
- Taxes. Income tax treatment of lease payments, depreciation and interest is left out, and so is sales tax, which some states charge on each lease payment rather than on the price up front. A tax professional can tell you how each option affects your business.
- An unknown end value. On a fair-market-value lease the buyout price is set at the end, not at signing. The calculator uses your estimate for both the buyout and the resale value.
- Return costs. Shipping, de-installation and charges for excess wear or hours on returned equipment.
- Renewal and notice clauses. Many leases renew automatically, often month to month at the same payment, unless you give written notice within a set window before the end.
- Early termination. Most equipment leases can't be cancelled; ending early usually means paying the remaining payments. On the loan side, prepayment penalties and variable rates aren't modeled either.
- Deposits and advance payments. A refundable security deposit is left out. If the lease collects the first and last payments at signing, the calculator counts the last one in the final month, so the lease looks slightly cheaper in today's dollars than it is.
- Insurance, maintenance and service. They're assumed to be the same either way. Some leases bundle service, which can justify a higher payment.
Equipment leases for business use usually quote a payment, not a rate, and the federal APR disclosure rules in Regulation Z generally don't cover business-purpose credit. Choosing "Buy it at the purchase option price" shows the lease's implied rate, so you can compare it with a loan rate yourself.
Common mistakes
- Comparing only the monthly payments. In the machine scenario the payments are only $36.94 apart, yet buying costs $17,174 less in today's dollars because you keep a $40,000 machine.
- Assuming the fair-market buyout will be cheap. Buying the machine at $40,000 at lease end makes the lease's implied rate 13.40%. If you expect to keep the equipment, compare a $1-out lease or a loan.
- Guessing the resale value high. Use dealer or auction prices for used equipment of the same age, not the price you hope for. Dropping the machine's end value from $40,000 to $25,000 cuts buying's lead from $17,174 to $5,486.
- Missing the notice window. Without written notice before the end, an automatically renewing lease keeps charging the full payment for equipment you've already paid for many times over.
- Assuming every lease is treated as a rental for taxes. A $1-out lease may be treated as a purchase. Ask a tax professional before choosing a lease for its tax effect.
- Signing a personal guarantee without reading it. Many small-business leases require one, which puts your own assets at risk if the business can't pay.
Leasing or buying equipment
A lease usually needs little or no money down and can include the purchase at the end. A $1-out (capital) lease is close to a loan, so compare its implied rate with loan offers. A fair-market-value lease has lower payments and suits equipment that becomes obsolete quickly, since you can return it. Buying costs more up front but you keep the equipment's resale value, which matters most for machinery that lasts. Taxes are left out because lease payments, depreciation and interest are handled differently for business taxes; a tax professional can tell you how each option affects yours. An SBA 7(a) loan can also be used to buy equipment; the SBA 7(a) loan calculator adds its guaranty fee. To size the loan side on its own, use the business loan calculator.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to lease or buy equipment?
Buying usually costs less overall for equipment you will keep and that holds its value, because you own it at the end. Leasing can cost less when the equipment loses value fast, when you would return it, or when you want to keep cash free. Compare both in today's dollars with your own numbers.
What is a $1 buyout lease?
A $1-out lease lets you buy the equipment for $1 at the end of the term. It works much like a loan: you pay for nearly the whole cost through the payments and keep the equipment. Its implied interest rate is the fairest way to compare it with a loan.
What is a fair-market-value lease?
A fair-market-value (FMV) lease lets you return the equipment, renew, or buy it at its market value when the lease ends. Payments are lower than on a $1-out lease because the lessor keeps the residual value.
What discount rate should I use?
Use what your cash would otherwise earn or save, such as the return on your business savings or the rate on debt you could pay down. A higher discount rate favors options that delay payments, which usually helps leasing.
What happens at the end of a fair-market-value lease?
You usually choose to return the equipment, renew the lease or buy it at its market value at that time. Read the notice clause: many leases renew automatically unless you tell the lessor in writing within a set window before the end, and returns can carry shipping and wear charges.
Can I end an equipment lease early?
Usually not without paying most or all of the remaining payments. Most equipment leases can't be cancelled, so choose a term no longer than you expect to need the equipment.
Why doesn't my lease quote show an interest rate?
Business equipment leases are usually priced as a payment, and the federal APR disclosure rules generally don't cover business-purpose credit. To find the rate, enter the lease with "Buy it at the purchase option price" and the calculator shows its implied interest rate.
Sources
- U.S. Small Business Administration: 7(a) loans (including equipment)
- CFPB: Regulation Z (Truth in Lending)
Last reviewed . How we review and test pages.